Story: , ,

Our cities are subject to the vagaries of other governments

Naheed Nenshi - formalI write a monthly column in the Calgary Herald. Here is my February story:

Indulge with me in some crystal ball gazing. When the Flames next win the Stanley Cup (this spring, of course!), it will be great for the city. Visitors will pack our hotels, restaurants and bars will be full, and people will be buying hockey sweaters and souvenirs. However, the City of Calgary — the municipality — will not receive one penny from any of this activity while incurring significant cost.

Even well-mannered Calgary crowds need policing and security — and then there’s street cleaning, infrastructure repair and even porta-potties. Not to mention the cost of the victory rally.

This is just one example (hopefully not that far-fetched) of how cities in this country work. We have limited resources and decision-making power, our budgets are stretched to the limit (and we don’t or can’t run deficits), yet we are expected to provide the services that keep people alive, healthy, safe and happy every day.

I was thinking about this not only because the mayor of Vancouver made the terrible mistake of trash-talking me during the Flames/Canucks game on Saturday night, but also because of the recent provincial budget and the upcoming election.

While this provincial budget won’t have an enormous impact on the city’s operations, it is a bit ridiculous that the duly elected government of over a million people (a larger population than five provinces), having passed its own budget months ago, and well into its own fiscal year, was huddled around the radio waiting to see if the decisions of another level of government would force us to change our plans.

Remember last year, when a footnote to a footnote in the provincial budget announced a $15 surcharge to traffic tickets that would have blown a multimillion-dollar hole in our own budget?

This year, the Alberta government’s budget was significantly more benign. While nothing in the budget should hurt Calgary too much (although we have not yet reviewed all the footnotes to the footnotes), it also misses some opportunities to make a positive difference to our city.

Take policing, for example. While there is a very large increase to the Solicitor-General’s budget, none of it appears to be coming to the large cities for our policing needs — it’s going to RCMP officers for rural Alberta and provincial sheriffs. This is despite the well-documented need to keep up policing resources and maintain Calgary’s status as one of the safest cities anywhere.

Similarly, while poverty and income support are not de facto the responsibility of cities, we end up dealing with their impacts on our streets and in our neighbourhoods. Increases to support programs such as AISH are, therefore, truly welcome.

However, the province chose not to make a modest increase to the program they cost share with the city: Family and Community Support Services. A small increase here would have gone directly to the scores of non-profit organizations doing hard work every day with people at risk, and it’s a shame the province chose not to help them more, despite the city unilaterally increasing its funding to the initiative.

(I voted against both of these increases in the fall budget debates, not because I thought they were bad investments, but precisely because I thought that the city taking unilateral action would let the province off the hook. It’s not clear if that was their motivation, but here we are again with the city left holding the bag.)

Even more perplexing, the province seems to be stepping back from its commitment to fund affordable housing in favour of funding shelter beds. We are still awaiting details on this, but, if it’s true, it would be a terrible mistake. Just last week, we announced that the number of homeless people in Calgary is down for the first time in 20 years, because of our new commitment to housing people, and because the province came to the table in a really meaningful way with significant funding.

All of this underlies the key point: Why can’t Calgarians make decisions and set priorities for ourselves? Why should we be subject to the vagaries of other governments? After all, it’s Calgary taxpayers who give the province the money in the first place — several billion dollars more each year than we get back in all provincial benefits.

In the upcoming election, therefore, I encourage you to ask tough questions: How can our cities have the tools to build the community and provide the services we all need? I know I will be asking these questions, and I will share the answers I get with you.

- Mayor Naheed Nenshi
Story: ,

Radio: Mayor Nenshi talks about "hobbled cities"


On February 13, 2012, Mayor Nenshi joined guest-host Jim Brown on CBC's The Current for a half-hour discussion about the powers of cities and city councils. The discussion included talk of the idea of the "strong mayor" (which Mayor Nenshi dislikes) and the challenging relationship between municipalities (especially large cities) and other levels of government. This was also the topic of Mayor Nenshi's recent column in the Calgary Herald.

- Daorcey from Mayor Nenshi's team
Story:

Media release: Funding solution for 4 new recreation centres

family at Village Square Leisure Centre

City Council agrees on funding solution for four new recreation centres

Solution allows for immediate development of Northwest, Great Plains, Quarry Park, and Seton recreation facilities

Today, Calgary City Council approved a new financing strategy that ensures four new recreation facilities in Calgary’s southeast and northwest will be built—without any impact to property taxes. This follows the withdrawal of $100 million by the federal government through PPP Canada.

“I am so happy that we will soon be able to build these critically-needed facilities,” said Mayor Naheed Nenshi. “I also want to thank my Council colleagues and City Administration for this creative solution.”

The recreation centres will be funded through a reallocation of existing money in the Community and Recreation Levy as well as a portion of the City’s GST rebate. No existing funded projects will be affected.

“City Council is committed to building these facilities for Calgarians within the original scope, wherever feasible,” said Alderman Gord Lowe.

Work is underway to determine design details, construction start and completion dates, method of delivery (P3 or traditional), and refined costing for the recreation facilities. Administration will report to Council about its progress in June 2012. Details regarding facility costing cannot be shared at this time due to confidentiality required for the procurement process.

“These new facilities will be amazing—and much-needed—spaces to play, learn, grow and connect for all Calgarians,” said Alderman Shane Keating. “Each facility is a critical component in developing healthy, vibrant and complete communities.”

- Daorcey from Mayor Nenshi's team

(photo above: a family plays in the wave pool at the Village Square Leisure Centre)
Story: ,

Mayor Nenshi Reads: Interrupting Chicken

nenshi reads shot

On January 27, Mayor Naheed Nenshi joined Calgary Reads to celebrate Family Literacy Day at his old school Marlborough School. Thanks to Calgary Reads and Hidden Story, we've captured Mayor Nenshi reading the children's story Interrupting Chicken to students in grades one and two.


For those who aren't familiar with the original joke on which this story is based, allow me to reproduce it here for your enjoyment:

Knock-knock.
Who's there?
Interrupting chicken.
Interrupting chicken wh--
Bwak! Bwak!

Classic. I'm still laughing.

- Daorcey from Mayor Nenshi's team
Story: ,

Mayor Nenshi's meetings: January 2012

Office sign photo

Below is a list of external meetings hosted by the Mayor during the month of January 2012.

For an explanation of why this list exists and who's on it, please visit our post about highlighting accountability in the Mayor's Office.

December's meetings included:
  • Johann Zietsman, Epcor Centre for the Performing Arts - January 17, 2012
  • Lisa Walli, Epcor Centre for the Performing Arts - January 17, 2012
  • Mohamud Zaver, Ismaili Council - January 18, 2012
  • Tim Hamilton, Odgers Berndtson - January 20, 2012
  • Michael Brown, Calgary Municipal Land Corporation - January 20, 2012
  • Goldy Hyder, Hill and Knowlton - January 25, 2012
  • Simon Vincent, Knightsbridge Human Capital Solutions - January 25, 2012
  • Jamie Niessen, Volunteer Calgary - January 31, 2012
- Daorcey from Mayor Nenshi's team
Story:

Media statement: Mayor Nenshi on Council compensation and donating 10% of his salary

Today, your City Council decided to accept the recommendations of the Council Compensation Review Committee. This means that Council compensation adjustments will continue to be tied to the Alberta Average Weekly Earnings (AWE) as calculated by Statistics Canada.

First of all, I want to thank the volunteer citizen committee that prepared an excellent report on City Council compensation. Their work did much to inform the debate and decisions today.

It is best to keep compensation out of the hands of politicians because that approach is predictable and transparent. While there are a number of ways to calculate compensation increases, I believe that the Consumer Price Index appears to be the most easily understood and transparent way to do this. That’s why I voted in favour of this change, which was ultimately defeated by Council. That said, there is very little difference between CPI and AWE. Over the last 20 years, the average increase has been within one percentage point of one another.

I was surprised to learn the value of the mayor’s compensation compared to mayors in other cities. For that reason, I will donate 10% of my 2012 salary to either the City of Calgary or a charity that does work in Calgary, which is consistent with what I did last year, though at a higher percentage. This donation will be in addition to my regular charitable giving in a normal year.

The reason I am structuring this as a donation rather than a pay cut is because it does not appear to be possible to change the remuneration for only one member of Council rather than for everyone.

I strongly feel that aldermen in Calgary are appropriately compensated for all the work they do. There are, for example, twice as many MLAs in Calgary as there are aldermen. A report tabled in December showed that the poorest-paid MLA in 2010-2011 earned about 30% more than a Calgary alderman. The average MLA earned about 60% more. Again, this is cash compensation only, not including benefits or transition allowance.

Your Council representatives work extremely hard to serve many citizens (more citizens per alderman than most Canadian cities, in fact) to the best of their abilities. They, as am I, are honoured to serve Calgarians every day.

Over the weekend, I researched and prepared a brief memo for my Council colleagues. The following excerpt explains my thoughts on the difference between Alberta Average Weekly Earnings and the Consumer Price Index.

Excerpt from the Mayor’s Briefing Memorandum
The adjustment formula

I think we generally agree that we should use an objective formula to set annual wage adjustments. I maintain that we should also retain and use the right to reduce (but never increase) proposed changes in times when the objective formula seems out of whack with economic reality.

Ald. Chabot has suggested that we use price inflation, as measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI), rather than wage inflation, as measured by Alberta Average Weekly Earnings (AWE), as our gauge. Others have suggested that we use the average wage change of city employees, though some suggest this would lead to a conflict of interest, since we also set the bargaining mandate for our labour negotiations.(I find this latter argument ludicrous on its face; I can’t imagine eight members of Council together voting to cost the City millions of dollars for a few hundred dollars of personal income, but the argument has been made.)

To inform our debate, I have plotted the CPI versus AWE annual change over the last 20 years.
As you can see, CPI has been below AWE for the last seven years, but AWE was equal to or below CPI for five years before that—they do tend to converge over time. The average over this time frame for CPI was 2.4% annually, and AWE was 3.2% annually. (These numbers are skewed a bit by the relatively large differences in the last two years. From 1992-2006, the averages were 2.4% CPI versus 2.8% AWE. The abnormality of the last two years is one of the reasons I argued that we should reduce the increase last year.)

While conceptually it makes some sense to tie our salaries to wage inflation, I have also found that many people find it more satisfying and easier to understand when it’s tied to price inflation, since that’s what all of us feel every day when we go to the grocery store or gas pump. I therefore support Ald. Chabot’s notion that CPI should be used rather than AWE this year and going forward.
- Mayor Naheed Nenshi
Story: ,

Celebrating 3 Things for Calgary

the "3" visits Bow to Bluff

Schools across Calgary are enthusiastically getting involved in the 3 Things for Calgary movement, and Sunalta School is a great example. At an all-student assembly yesterday, Mayor Nenshi's Chief of Staff Chima Nkemdirim spoke with students and teachers about how they could get more involved in making Calgary even better.

You can read Metro's coverage of the event here.

And here's an excerpt from the Calgary Herald article about Sunalta School's take on 3 Things for Calgary: 
Some civic-minded youngsters have taken on a challenge from the mayor to do three things to make Calgary a better place before the end of the year.
Around 300 students from a southwest school made the pledge Tuesday, collectively promising to make nearly 900 contributions to their street, neighbourhood and city by the spring.
An initiative of the mayor’s civic engagement committee, 3 Things for Calgary was launched in October with the goal of getting Calgarians to take on projects that benefit their community.
“The idea is that we’re all part of a community and we can all do stuff to make that community better,” said Chima Nkemdirim, the mayor’s chief of staff. “You can pick the thing — big or small. It could be helping to organize your kid’s little league team or inviting your neighbours over for a barbecue in the summer.”
In a speech to the Rotary Club of Calgary on Tuesday, Mayor Naheed Nenshi said the campaign was devised by volunteers.
There are many ways to give back, he said, some big and some small.
“My single favourite example is the guy who told me, ‘I’m going to have a barbecue, but I’m going to have it in my front yard instead of my backyard. And I’m going to invite all the neighbours I don’t really know,’” he said.
At a school assembly Tuesday, Sunalta students took turns sharing what their three things might be.
“Shovelling my neighbour’s sidewalk” and “Picking up garbage off the street” were popular, but “Listening to my mom and dad” drew appreciative nods from the adults in the room.
Principal Kel Connelly said the project fits well with the Calgary Board of Education’s curriculum emphasis on developing students’ sense of citizenship...
So, what are your three things for Calgary?

- Daorcey from Mayor Nenshi's team