Story: , ,

Interview: Calgary's rental market and secondary suites

This morning, Mayor Nenshi called into CBC's Eyeopener to discuss affordable housing and his plans to bring the issue of safe and legal secondary suites to City Council. Listen to the full interview.

- Posted by Daorcey from Mayor Nenshi's team
Story: ,

You can help every Calgarian find a home

moonrise-mullin-600

To coincide with National Housing Day, I co-wrote the following article in the Calgary Herald. We need to continue to work hard at ending homelessness in our great city. If our fellow citizens can not afford to buy or rent a home or are plagued by poverty, we are all lesser.

Calgary is a vibrant and prospering city, playing a key role in the economic strength and social health of our province and the nation as a whole. And yet, amidst this prosperity, housing is out of reach for some. In a count done the night of Aug. 15, more than 3,500 people were homeless in Calgary. And migration to Calgary is driving the need for homeless shelter spaces up, with as many as 250 additional beds needed this winter.

Although our city is ranked as one of Canada’s most affordable big cities, this measure is relative. Not everyone can generate the income to buy a home, with prices averaging well over $400,000. Rent is equally challenging, with a one-bedroom apartment in Calgary priced at around $1,000 per month and the vacancy rate hovering at around two per cent.

In the first three months of this year, more than 14,000 people from outside of Alberta came to the province looking for work — many of those to Calgary. It’s important they have access to the quality of life that makes Calgary such an appealing place to live and work, including suitable shelter, where their families can live in comfort, safety and pride.

One recent survey suggests Canadians don’t fully realize the urgent need for affordable housing. An estimated 1.5 million Canadian families live in “core housing need,” yet only 11 per cent of Canadians think of affordable housing as an issue in their neighbourhood. A study done by the U of C’s faculty of social work found that about 14,000 rental households in Calgary are at high risk of becoming homeless because more than half of their income goes to rent and they make less than $20,000 per year.

Lack of affordable housing can cause increased stress, limited sense of belonging and overall feelings of insecurity. It can also hinder an individual’s education and career paths, which further perpetuates the cycle of poverty. Poverty and homelessness are also expensive for Alberta taxpayers. Simply managing poverty will cost the government of Alberta up to $9.5 billion per year in public services, like health care, in crime, and in lost economic opportunities for children and people living in poverty, according to a study by A. Briggs and C.R. Lee done this year.

Affordable housing leads to healthier and more productive communities. Areas of health, education and financial and emotional well-being are improved. Good housing attracts economic investment, and contributes to thriving schools and community organizations.

The City of Calgary and other organizations are finding ways to close the gap, even as the city grows. The 10 Year Plan to End Homelessness, a partnership between the Calgary Homeless Foundation and the Calgary Action Committee on Housing and Homelessness, is one example in which agencies work to provide people with housing and support rather than trying to manage homelessness through emergency measures.

Calgary was the first city to have a 10-year plan and Alberta was the first province in Canada to follow suit. In the first four years of Calgary’s 10-year plan, more than 4,000 people received housing and support. Another example is the Calgary Poverty Reduction Initiative, launched in the spring, which aims to reduce the number of people living in poverty.

Habitat for Humanity Southern Alberta’s home ownership model is another example. Habitat uses volunteer labour and donated funds and building materials to build safe, decent homes that are sold to low-income families with mortgage payments they can afford. This “hand-up” approach enables families to end their dependency on social housing subsidies. They save money, contribute to the economy and pay between $1,100 and $2,300 each year in property taxes.

Today, National Housing Day, provides Canadians with an opportunity to reflect on the importance of affordable housing in our communities. We need to acknowledge there is a desperate need for adequate housing. We know Calgarians are action-oriented and find such disparity unacceptable. So, this is a call to act. We need volunteers and funds to meet these goals, but we also need the less tangible gifts that will make the seemingly impossible happen. Some of it will involve cutting unnecessary red tape and clearing the way for such easy, short-term approaches as legalizing secondary suites in more communities.

At other times, it will be an engineering solution, such as the clever micro-house designs in development that can fit on small lots or, in some cases, even remain mobile. Or it may include providing land on which to build affordable homes. Forward-thinking community planners have had success including affordable housing in new developments.

The authors of this piece each have their own causes, but are united in their belief that shelter is a basic right. The City of Calgary, Habitat for Humanity Southern Alberta, the Calgary Homeless Foundation, The Calgary Action Committee on Housing and Homelessness and Calgary’s Realtors all share the belief that every Calgarian has the right to live in safety and security.

History has shown time and again that the citizens of this city feel the same way — and have the heart and drive to make things happen. Let your elected official know affordable housing is important to you. And share your ideas, time, money and household items so we can turn this ideal into a reality.

The Authors

Bob Jablonski is president of the Calgary Real Estate Board
Naheed Nenshi is mayor of Calgary
John Rook is president and CEO of the Calgary Homeless Foundation
Walter Twiddy is chair of the Calgary Action Committee on Housing and Homelessness
Leslie Tamagi is president and CEO of Habitat for Humanity Southern Alberta

- Mayor Naheed Nenshi
Story: ,

Media Statement: Council's decision regarding legalizing secondary suites

Mayor Nenshi-7154
Today is an important first step in the legalization of safe secondary suites in Calgary.

By eliminating red tape at City Hall, we are making it easier for many Calgarians to create legal and safe secondary suites in those communities that already allow such suites.

In addition to this, my Council colleagues and I have asked City Administration to return to Council in December with recommendations on how we may allow and enforce safe and legal secondary suites in all communities in Calgary.

City Council has also directed the Administration to make recommendations to the provincial government regarding those aspects of the building code that make it unnecessarily costly to develop a safe secondary suite.

This is not the end of this very important discussion about the future of our city. I have spoken about the need for safe, legal secondary suites for some time, and I continue to believe that it is important to move forward on this issue for a number of reasons—most importantly the safety of our neighbours.

I want to thank the many Calgarians and local organizations who engaged in a public discussion about this important issue. It’s clear from the public engagement and scientific polls that Calgarians are ready to move forward on secondary suites. I will continue to work with my colleagues on City Council to make further progress on this issue.

- Mayor Nenshi
Story: ,

Most Calgarians back secondary suites--here's hoping Council does

Every month, I write a column in the Calgary Herald. Here is the full text of my March story:

On Monday your city council will debate a key issue about the future of our city and the kind of community in which we want to live.

I have long been in favour of making changes to how we regulate secondary suites. I've written about it on this page for years, and it was the very first plank in my platform in the recent election.

I spoke about it every day, with thousands of Calgarians, who told me, and continue to tell me, that they agree we need change.

And we do. We have willingly created a system where many of our neighbours live without the protections that the rest of us enjoy.

As I have often said, if the smoke detector doesn't work, if there are mice, if there is mould, if there is no heat, tenants have nowhere to turn. And we, as a city, cannot help them. We have only one tool, which is to tear out the stove and kick people out of their homes.

We can't go after the slumlords and the bad landlords because we have to treat them the same as the good responsible landlords.

We've all heard the arguments many times, and Calgarians understand them. One of my colleagues is fond of saying "we need to ask people" and on this page a former alderman said we need to listen to "ordinary taxpayers."

I agree.

But here's the thing. We have asked. And over and over and over again, people have told us to follow the lead of every other city in Canada, to stop ignoring the needs of our neighbours, and to stop pretending that our current system makes any sense. Council needs to listen.

We had a public hearing (the public is very welcome to attend Council on Monday, but there will not be an opportunity to address us during the debate).

Twenty-five submissions were made by Calgarians who gave up their day to be there. Two or three spoke against the proposal, the rest were in favour - that's about 90 per cent.

An unprecedented array of citizen groups have also stood up in favour. All major business groups, including the chamber of commerce, have stood shoulder-to-shoulder with anti-poverty groups, social agencies, and student associations to call for this change. The Roman Catholic Diocese even sent a letter encouraging all parishioners to support this change.

Further, in the recent election, 66 per cent of voters voted for a mayoral candidate who made this change a priority (most of the rest voted for someone who promised change, but did not specify exactly what change).

And on Thursday, a scientific poll was released that showed a vast majority of Calgarians support legalizing suites across the city. Some 75 per cent support development of secondary suites in their own neighbourhoods.

A full 77 per cent of Calgarians say they're happy to have a secondary suite next door. Seventy-nine per cent support legalization of existing suites.

This is true in every neighbourhood in every corner of the city and across all demographics.

Not only is this absolutely consistent with all other polling that's ever been done on this issue, it is as close to consensus as we get in municipal politics. We could not get that many Calgarians to agree that this winter has been too long.

So why all the controversy?

It's easy to say that the kind of people who have their alderman on speed dial are the only people opposed to this change (indeed, it's worth noting that the same survey suggested that only seven per cent of citizens knew their community association's position in the matter, highlighting that on this issue, the loud voices are not speaking for their neighbours).

But we should also understand that there are some real concerns and real fears about what this change will bring, even if these fears belong to a small minority.

The good news is that, since we are the last major city to make this change, we have a very good idea of what will happen after this change is made.

The take-up to build new secondary suites is likely to be modest in early years. In Edmonton, between 2007-10, about 100 new suites have been built on average annually -one or two in each neighbourhood.

However, this allows for the creation of safe legal alternatives, which gives us the power to go after the bad landlords. We can work with them to bring their suites to code, or we can shut them down without worrying about where those tenants will go.

Our plan is not a panacea. It won't solve the problem of affordable housing forever. There will still be some illegal suites.

But it will go a long way to fixing the current bad situation. It will allow us to do the right thing for our community and for our future. It will allow us to protect landlords, tenants and neighbours in a way that has not been possible under our current system.

I don't know what will happen on Monday. I've long said that I let good ideas come to council and let them stand on their merits, rather than only debating foregone conclusions and pre-cooked plans. There will be a great deal of discussion, and there may be some interesting new ideas proposed.

We may even decide, as politicians love to do, that more study is needed.

I encourage you all to lend your voices to the debate. Please pick up the phone or the keyboard today and contact my office and your alderman.

You can reach us by dialing 311 or visiting the city's website. On this, and many other issues that will come before council, we need to hear from you.

- Mayor Nenshi
Story: ,

Media Release: Recent secondary suites poll shows strong support for legalization and poor representation of citizens

Thursday, March 3 – Calgary, AB: A survey released today reinforces that the vast majority of Calgarians are ready to legalize safe secondary suites in their communities, however, the poll also indicates that many community associations are not reflecting the views of their constituents.

Commissioned by the University of Calgary Students’ Union and conducted ZINC Research, the new poll confirmed previous research and asked new questions that were previously unexplored.

“These results illustrate something that I’ve been hearing for some time: that Calgarians support legal secondary suites,” said Mayor Nenshi. “But the poll also shows that 77 per cent of Calgarians are comfortable with their neighbours building legal secondary suites as close as right next door.”

The research explores Calgarians’ awareness of the issue showing that, while many know Mayor Nenshi’s position on legalizing secondary suites, few know the position of their own community associations which have traditionally spoken for the people of a community.
  • 57 per cent of Calgarians polled are aware of the Mayor Nenshi’s position
  • Seven per cent of Calgarians polled are aware of their community association’s position
“Some community associations support the legalization of secondary suites and some do not,” said Mayor Nenshi. “What this demonstrates is that those community associations that have been vocal in their opposition do not reflect the true views of the people who live in their communities.”

Due to the large sample size of the research (1,585 respondents), Calgarians can see a snapshot of opinion in some of the city wards. Although there is some slight variation between wards, most wards reflect the opinion of the entire city. For example, Wards 1 and 6 (located in west Calgary) and Wards 13 and 14 (located in east Calgary) are within a range of 72 per cent to 79 per cent in support for their neighbours building secondary suites next door.

“It is important to me to lead with the best available facts and information,” said Mayor Nenshi. “This survey strongly reinforces information we’ve known previously, and reminds me that we are doing what is right for the future of Calgary and its citizens.”

The ZINC Research poll results mirror the results of a study conducted by Mustel Group in 2009 for The City of Calgary.
  • 79 per cent of Calgarians polled favour legalization of existing secondary suites
  • 75 per cent of Calgarians polled support secondary suites in their neighbourhood
The detailed results of the research can be found here.

- Daorcey from Mayor Nenshi's team
Story:

Video: Mayor Nenshi on the need to legalize secondary suites in Calgary

A brief video from Mayor Nenshi presenting some of the many reasons to legalize secondary suites throughout Calgary.



- Daorcey from Mayor Nenshi's team
Story: ,

City needs courage on secondary suites

Mayor Nenshi-7154I write a monthly column for the Calgary Sun. Here is an excerpt from my February article:

Over the next few weeks, you will hear a lot of discussion and debate around secondary suites in Calgary.

It’s no secret that I strongly believe we need a change.

Currently, there are somewhere between 10,000 and 50,000 suites in Calgary.

No one knows the real number, because the vast majority of them are illegal.

What we do know is that they are in every neighbourhood in the city, and that most of the tenants are good neighbours.

But we also know that these people — our neighbours — live in a world without the protections that the rest of us enjoy.

If their landlord is abusing them, if the smoke detectors don’t work, if there’s no heat, if there is mould or a mouse infestation, they have nowhere to turn.

The city only has one option, which is to rip out the stove and kick them out of their homes.

Furthermore, if the city were to crack down on these illegal suites and somehow close them all down, we would have an affordable housing crisis like none we have ever seen.

In a world where we are proud to create a few hundred new units of affordable housing per year, how would we ever replace tens of thousands of units?

So, we’ve created a “don’t ask, don’t tell” situation that treats thousands of our fellow citizens in a way we would not want to be treated ourselves.

There are many who argue that allowing any homeowner to apply for a suite would irrevocably change neighbourhoods, would lead to a parking nightmare, and would have the “wrong kind” of people move in.

While I disagree that having renters is bad for a community, it’s important to note that these arguments have nothing to do with secondary suites in particular.

If an owner wants to rent a house to members of a university fraternity, or if a family has four teenage kids and nine cars on the street, they are completely within their rights to do so and normal bylaws apply.

If they are bad neighbours, people can call 311 and complain about noise, waste, unkempt yards, and so on.

It’s only by adding a stove that suddenly a whole new set of rules apply.

Recall the woman with MS who wanted to put a suite in so that she could have a tenant help with yard work.

It cost her thousands of dollars and many months, culminating in her having to come before city council and plead her case in front of 15 strangers, live on TV, explaining the intimate details of her life and begging for the right to do with as she needed with her own property.

This isn’t right.

My proposal to council is that we allow homeowners across the city to apply for a permit for a secondary suite if they desire, subject to three criteria...

Read the full article at the Calgary Sun.

- Mayor Nenshi